Seller protection
7 Junk Car Buyer Scams and How to Avoid Each One
Most junk car scams come down to one move: change the deal after you've stopped shopping around. The price drops when the tow truck arrives, a fee appears, or the payment never does. Here are the seven tricks to watch for, how to shut each one down, and how we handle the same moments ourselves.
Key takeaways
- Don't hand over the title, the keys or the car until payment is in your hand.
- Before you book a pickup, ask when the price can change and what you'll actually be handed after any fees.
- Write the buyer's name on the title yourself. Never sign a title with the buyer line left blank.
- File your state's release of liability the day the car leaves, no matter who bought it.
- Our offers change only if the car isn't as described or the details change. In the last 90 days, 90.8% of sales were paid exactly the amount first accepted.
The rule that beats most of them
Don’t hand over the title, the keys or the car until payment is in your hand. Nearly every trick below needs you to break that rule, or to feel too rushed to call anyone else. If a buyer’s process doesn’t let you follow it, pick another buyer.
The 7 tricks
1. The price drop at pickup
The buyer gives you a strong number on the phone. Then the tow truck driver “finds” problems and offers far less. It works because you’ve already cleaned out the car and told everyone it’s sold.
Protect yourself: Describe the car accurately, then ask one thing before you book: “When can the price change, and how often does it?” A fair answer names specific reasons, like missing parts, damage you didn’t mention or a title problem. A vague answer tells you what pickup day will look like. If the price drops for a reason that isn’t real, say no. The truck can leave empty.
2. Surprise towing and “admin” fees
The offer holds, but the payment comes up short. There’s a towing charge, a “processing” fee or a title fee nobody mentioned.
Protect yourself: Ask for the amount you’ll actually be handed, and get it in writing. A text or email counts. Compare buyers on that number only.
3. Pay later, or a check that bounces
The driver takes the car and promises payment “once the office processes it,” or leaves a check that later fails. Your bank may make the money available within a day or two and then take it back out of your account when the check bounces.
Protect yourself: Get paid before the car is loaded. A check is not a red flag by itself; plenty of legitimate buyers pay that way, and our partners often do. What matters is whose check it is. It should come from a business you were told to expect, not a personal account. Ask what happens if the check fails, deposit it right away, and keep a photo of it.
4. “We’ll mail you the check”
This is the same trick with a stamp on it. The car and the title leave today, and the payment is always a few days out. Once the car is gone, you have nothing left to bargain with.
Protect yourself: No payment, no pickup. A legitimate buyer can pay when they take the car.
5. The open title
The buyer asks you to sign the title but leave the buyer’s name blank. They may say the office fills it in later, or that it saves you time. A signed title with no buyer on it lets the car be passed along with no record of who took it from you.
Protect yourself: Write the buyer’s name on the title yourself, in ink, before you sign. Photograph both sides. Our guide to signing over a car title covers every line.
6. Title skipping
Here the buyer never puts the car in their own name. They resell it on your signature, which dodges taxes and fees and is generally against state law. The risk lands on you: state records can still show you as the owner, so parking tickets, toll bills and impound notices show up in your mailbox.
Protect yourself: File your state’s release of liability or notice of sale the day the car leaves, if your state has one. Keep a bill of sale with the buyer’s name, the date, the time and the VIN. The after-sale checklist has the full list.
7. “Pull the catalytic converter first”
Someone tells you to cut off the catalytic converter and sell it separately, often to them, because “the yard doesn’t pay for it anyway.” Then the offer on the car drops by more than the converter brought. Many states also restrict who can sell a detached converter and what proof they need, so you can end up holding a part you can’t easily sell.
Protect yourself: Leave the car whole. If a part is already missing, say so when you ask for an offer, so the number you get is real.
Red flags before you book a pickup
Any one of these is a reason to slow down.
- The buyer won’t give a business name or a physical address.
- The price can change “depending on what the driver sees,” with no list of reasons.
- Nobody will confirm the amount in writing.
- They want the title signed before they arrive, or with lines left blank.
- They push you to decide right now.
- They never ask about the title at all. A buyer who doesn’t care about paperwork won’t take care of yours.
How Lemondrove handles the same seven moments
We run this site, so weigh our answers the way you’d weigh anyone’s. Here is what we commit to.
| Trick | What happens with us |
|---|---|
| Price drop at pickup | The offer changes only if the car isn’t as described or the details change after you accept, such as a missing catalytic converter, damage that wasn’t mentioned or a title problem. |
| Surprise fees | Towing is free. There are no seller fees of any kind. |
| Pay later, bad checks | You’re paid at pickup, by check or cash. If a partner’s check ever fails, Lemondrove pays the full amount. |
| “We’ll mail it” | You are paid at pickup. |
| Open title | Fill in the buyer’s name at pickup. Don’t leave it blank for us or for anyone. |
| Title skipping | We won’t buy a car on a jumped title. Write the buyer’s name on yours, and file your release of liability. |
| Converter pressure | The converter is counted in your offer. Leave it on. |
Now the honest part. An offer from us is not unconditional. If the car arrives missing parts, or with damage that wasn’t in the description, the price changes, and you’re free to say no. We track how often the amount changes and publish it: in the last 90 days, 90.8% of sales were paid exactly the amount first accepted. The full terms are in our price promise.
You also see your offer before you give us a name, phone number or email.
If it has already gone wrong
Move quickly, and keep everything in writing.
- File the release of liability or notice of sale today, if your state has one. It puts the date you gave up the car on record.
- Save the evidence. Texts, emails, the ad or website, photos of the title, the check and the truck.
- Ask for payment in writing. A dated message helps you later.
- Report it. Local police handle theft and bad checks. Your state attorney general’s consumer protection office and the FTC take fraud reports. Your DMV can tell you how to deal with a title that was never transferred.
This is general information, not legal advice. Rules differ by state, and the state guide is the place to start.
Common questions
Can a junk car buyer lower the price at pickup?
A buyer can ask, and you can say no. A fair buyer changes the price only when the car is different from what was described, and tells you the possible reasons before pickup. If the driver cuts the price for a reason that isn't real, keep your title and keys and let the truck leave empty. The sale isn't done until you sign and get paid.
Is it safe to take a check for a junk car?
It can be. Plenty of legitimate buyers pay by check, including our partners. Make sure the check comes from a business you were told to expect, ask what happens if it fails, and deposit it right away. Be careful with personal checks and with anyone who wants to pay you later. If a partner's check ever fails on a Lemondrove sale, we pay the full amount.
What is title skipping, and why does it matter to me?
Title skipping, also called title jumping, is when a buyer resells your car without ever putting it in their own name. State records can keep showing you as the owner, so tickets, tolls and impound notices may come to you. Writing the buyer's name on the title and filing a release of liability are your protection.
Should I remove the catalytic converter before I junk my car?
No. A complete car is worth more than a car plus a loose converter in nearly every case, and many states restrict who can sell a detached converter. If someone pushes you to cut it off first, treat that as a warning sign about the buyer.
What should I do if a buyer took my car and didn't pay?
Act the same day. File your state's release of liability or notice of sale, write to the buyer asking for payment, and gather your photos, texts and bill of sale. Then report it to local police and your state attorney general's consumer protection office. This is general information, not legal advice.
These purchases were made by The Clunker Junker, the company that operates Lemondrove. Lemondrove launched in 2026 and its purchases join the same record.
That lemon isn't getting any sweeter.
See what it's worth today. It's free, it takes about 90 seconds, and you don't have to sell.