Calculator
Fix it or sell it?
The shop just handed you a number that made you sit down. Before you pay it, run it against what your car is actually worth, fixed and broken. The math is simple and every figure is on the page, so you can check it.
Worked example: 2012 Honda Accord that won't drive, $4,250 repair quote
Sell it as-is.
The repair costs more than the car would be worth running (397% of its value). Fixing it first would leave you $3,925 worse off than selling it today.
"Fix, then sell" is the running value minus the repair. "Repair vs. value" is the quote as a share of what the car is worth running. Car values are medians from our own purchases; the repair figure is whatever you type in.
What repairs cost vs. what broken cars sell for
Ballpark independent-shop quotes next to what we actually paid, on average, over the last 90 days. Sellers tell us the car's condition, not what broke, so the small print under each average says which cars it covers. The repair ranges are rough guides, not our data: your own quote is the number that matters.
| Problem | Ballpark repair quote | Avg. offer as-is | Repair ÷ offer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wrecked or totaled | $2,500 to $9,000 | $515 doesn't drive, body damage | 11.2× |
| Blown engine | $3,000 to $8,000 | $485 engine won't start | 11.3× |
| Bad transmission | $2,500 to $6,000 | $620 starts but won't drive | 6.9× |
| Won't start | $150 to $2,500 | $485 engine won't start | 2.7× |
| Blown head gasket | $1,500 to $3,500 | $485 engine won't start | 5.2× |
| Rusted out | $1,500 to $6,000 | $536 doesn't drive | 7.0× |
| Failed inspection or emissions | $400 to $2,600 | $563 every car we bought | 2.7× |
| Missing catalytic converter | $1,000 to $3,000 | $480 converter missing | 4.2× |
| Flood damage | $3,000 to $12,000 | $440 flood or fire damage | 17.0× |
How the math works
There are really two questions hiding inside "should I fix it?", and people mix them up.
1. Would fixing it make me money?
Take what the car is worth running and subtract the repair. That is what you net if you fix it and then sell. Compare it with what the car is worth today, broken. If fixing leaves you with less, the repair is a donation to the next owner.
For most major repairs on cars over ten years old, it does leave you with less. A new transmission does not add its cost to the car's value; it only restores the value the car would have had anyway.
2. Is the car worth keeping?
Different question. If you would drive it another five years, the repair is competing with a car payment, not with resale value. Here a common rule of thumb is 50%: once one repair costs more than half of what the car is worth running, you are concentrating a lot of money in a machine with other old parts waiting their turn.
What the calculator can't see
- The next repair. It prices this one fix, not the water pump behind it.
- Quote creep. Estimates grow once a shop opens things up. Leave room for it.
- How much you like the car. That is allowed to count. It just isn't worth money.
Still torn? Read sell, trade in, donate or scrap for the other ways out.
Questions about fixing vs. selling
When is a car not worth fixing?
When the repair costs more than the difference between what the car is worth fixed and what it is worth broken, and you do not plan to keep it. A common rule of thumb is to think hard once a single repair passes 50% of the car's running value.
Where do the values come from?
From our own purchases since 2021: the median we paid for that model and model year, for cars that drive and for cars that don't. They are what a buyer like us pays, not retail prices, and the gap between the two is small. If you would sell privately, raise the "worth running" figure to match local listings.
Does the calculator account for future repairs?
No, and that is the biggest thing it leaves out. An older car that needs a transmission today often needs something else within a year. Treat a "toss-up" as a lean toward selling.
What if I want to keep the car?
Then compare the repair to the cost of replacing the car, not to its resale value. A repair on a car you know and trust can beat a monthly car payment. The calculator answers the narrower question: which choice leaves more money in your pocket today.
Know your as-is number before you decide.
An offer takes about 90 seconds and costs nothing. Then the calculator is working with a real figure instead of an average.