Research · Annual report
The State of the American Lemon, 2026
This is our first yearly look at the cars we bought. Over the last 12 months the typical one was 18.2 years old and had about 180,000 miles on it. One that didn't drive averaged $610 in 2026 (January to October). Here is the full picture.
The year in five numbers
$610average offer for a car that doesn't drive, 2026 (January to October) up 8.0 percent vs. 2025
18.2 yrsaverage age at sale, last 12 months
180,000average miles at sale, last 12 months
56%of pickups scheduled within two days of the seller accepting, last 90 days
45.1%of cars bought since 2021 had body damage, the most common condition reported
Figures through October 2026. Each one says the period it covers.
1. Prices
The Lemon Index averaged $610 in 2026 (January to October), up 8.0% from the 2025 average. That is the highest annual average on record so far, and 4.3 times the 2016 low of $143. The year is not over: the monthly figure was $519 in October 2026.
The Index measures what we paid, so it moves with our own buying as well as with the market. Since 2016 it has risen 4.3 times, while the public price index for scrap iron and steel rose 1.8 times. The long-run climb is therefore more than scrap: which cars we buy, and where they can be resold, changed over those years too. How to read the trend.
2. The ten models we buy most
Popularity when new, plus about 18 years, equals a place on this list. These are the models we bought most often since 2021.
| Rank | Model | Type | Typical offer | Sales counted | Most-sold year |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Honda Accord | Sedan | $410 | 14,318 | 2002 |
| 2 | Toyota Camry | Sedan | $440 | 13,674 | 2007 |
| 3 | Nissan Altima | Sedan | $415 | 11,780 | 2005 |
| 4 | Honda Civic | Small car | $450 | 11,628 | 2005 |
| 5 | Ford Focus | Small car | $405 | 9,899 | 2012 |
| 6 | Ford Escape | SUV | $485 | 9,803 | 2008 |
| 7 | Ford Explorer | SUV | $440 | 8,707 | 2002 |
| 8 | Ford F-150 | Pickup | $515 | 8,494 | 2004 |
| 9 | Toyota Corolla | Small car | $610 | 8,081 | 2005 |
| 10 | Chevrolet Impala | Sedan | $380 | 8,062 | 2008 |
3. How old is a lemon?
Older than you might think. The average car sold to us in the past year was 18.2 years old, counting from its model year to the year of the sale.
4. What shape they were in
We ask sellers what shape the car is in, not what broke or why they are selling, and a car can have more than one thing wrong. Among cars bought since 2021, body damage was reported on 45.1%, engine won't start on 38.2% and starts and drives on 37.8%. Our companion study, What Shape Cars Are In When They're Sold, breaks this down by make and model.
The economics are unforgiving at this age. A car that still runs brought a median of $70 more than the same model and year that didn't, which is far less than any major repair costs. See The Repair Bill That Totals Your Car.
5. Where lemons are worth the most
Location moves the price, and so does what people drive there. These rankings cover the 30 states where we bought at least 250 cars in the last 90 days; in smaller states an average is a handful of cars and swings from month to month. Averages are for cars that don't drive. Every state has its own page under title rules by state.
6. Timing
Averaged across the years on record, offers run highest in March and lowest in October. March was above its yearly trend in 11 of 11 years. The swing is worth about $56 on a typical car. Full seasonality study.
7. Where they went
After purchase a car is resold at auction, dismantled for parts, or recycled. We do not track which path each car takes, so we publish no split. What happens to your car after you sell it follows the trip.
8. How we did
We hold ourselves to the same standard of disclosure. In the last 90 days, 90.8% of sales were paid exactly the amount the seller first accepted, 6.1% were paid less and 3.1% were paid more. Why an offer changed is not recorded. The details are in the No Sour Surprises pledge.
That lemon isn't getting any sweeter.
See what it's worth today. It's free, it takes about 90 seconds, and you don't have to sell.