Research · Condition at sale
What Shape Cars Are In When They're Sold
Every seller tells us what shape the car is in before they see an offer: does it start, does it drive, is the body straight, is the converter still there. Nobody is asked what broke or why they are selling. Across the cars bought since 2021, here is what those answers add up to.
Key findings
- 62.2% can't move under their own power: 38.2% won't start, and another 24% start but won't drive.
- 37.8% still start and drive on the day they are sold.
- The Nissan Rogue has the highest share of cars that start but won't drive of any high-volume model: 39.6%, against 24% overall.
- The Toyota Prius is the model most often sold with its catalytic converter missing: 5.9%, about 5 times the rate for all cars.
From sellers' answers in the offer form, for cars bought since 2021. A car can be in more than one row, so the shares add up to more than 100%. The selling pages show the same answers for the last 90 days only, so their shares differ a little.
What we can and can't tell you
We ask about the car, not about the repair bill. So we know that a car won't start. We don't know whether that is a seized engine, a failed fuel pump or a dead battery, and we won't guess. The same goes for a car that starts but won't move: that answer can mean the transmission, an axle, a brake or something else.
What the answers do show is where the pattern departs from the average. Body damage and no-starts are common on every model. When a model's sellers report one condition far more often than sellers of other models do, that is worth knowing; the answers alone don't say why.
Read this the right way. These are the cars that were sold to us, not every car on the road. A model with a high share here isn't necessarily unreliable: the answers record the condition of the cars sold, not its cause.
Make by make
| Make | Most often reported | Share | Next | Sales counted |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ford | Body damage | 46% | Starts and drives (38%) | 74,346 |
| Chevrolet | Body damage | 47% | Engine won't start (38%) | 62,343 |
| Toyota | Body damage | 53% | Starts and drives (40%) | 43,858 |
| Honda | Body damage | 51% | Starts and drives (40%) | 41,771 |
| Nissan | Body damage | 44% | Starts and drives (40%) | 36,735 |
| Dodge | Body damage | 50% | Engine won't start (40%) | 28,831 |
| Hyundai | Body damage | 45% | Engine won't start (40%) | 21,910 |
| Jeep | Body damage | 41% | Engine won't start (38%) | 17,778 |
| Chrysler | Body damage | 45% | Engine won't start (41%) | 16,831 |
| Kia | Engine won't start | 43% | Body damage (41%) | 15,227 |
| Volkswagen | Engine won't start | 40% | Body damage (39%) | 11,676 |
| Buick | Body damage | 41% | Starts and drives (40%) | 11,664 |
| Subaru | Body damage | 42% | Starts and drives (41%) | 10,963 |
| Mazda | Body damage | 48% | Engine won't start (38%) | 10,252 |
| Pontiac | Body damage | 48% | Starts and drives (40%) | 9,436 |
| BMW | Engine won't start | 42% | Starts and drives (36%) | 8,833 |
| GMC | Body damage | 42% | Starts and drives (39%) | 8,302 |
| Saturn | Engine won't start | 41% | Starts and drives (39%) | 7,384 |
| Mercedes-Benz | Starts and drives | 41% | Engine won't start (38%) | 6,016 |
| Mercury | Body damage | 47% | Starts and drives (42%) | 5,799 |
| Acura | Body damage | 44% | Starts and drives (41%) | 5,718 |
| Cadillac | Engine won't start | 41% | Starts and drives (38%) | 5,404 |
| Mitsubishi | Body damage | 50% | Engine won't start (44%) | 4,836 |
| Volvo | Starts and drives | 39% | Engine won't start (38%) | 4,447 |
| Lexus | Body damage | 42% | Starts and drives (40%) | 4,385 |
Makes with at least 4,000 sales in the data. Honda has the highest share of missing converters of any of them: 1.9%.
What this means if you own one
- Before a big repair, look up your model. If your car is in the condition its model shows most, the prices on its page already reflect that. Each model page shows its own breakdown.
- A car that starts is worth more than one that doesn't. If yours still runs, say so, even if it runs badly. Our pages on transmissions and no-starts explain what moves the price.
- Say so if the converter is missing. A missing converter takes real money off any offer, ours included, and one that wasn't mentioned can change an offer at pickup. See selling a car without one.
- When it's done, it's still worth something. Every row on this page has a price. The fix-or-sell calculator will tell you which side of the line you are on.
That lemon isn't getting any sweeter.
See what it's worth today. It's free, it takes about 90 seconds, and you don't have to sell.